Secretary with a messy desk yelling on the phone

She expected a $4,000 tax refund. When the check arrived it was $500. Her tax preparer had deposited the full refund into her own account and kept $3,500 as processing fees, an amount she never disclosed before filing the return. The preparer had framed the arrangement as a convenience, taking her fee directly from the refund so the client wouldn’t have to pay upfront. What she didn’t disclose was that the fee would consume nearly the entire refund.

She recently came across a news story about a tax preparer in Tennessee who was indicted for running the same scheme, and she learned afterward that the IRS specifically advises taxpayers never to allow a preparer to have a refund deposited into the preparer’s own account. She didn’t know that guidance existed when she agreed to the arrangement.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

What this actually is and why it matters for recovery

What her tax preparer did isn’t just a fee dispute. It’s a scheme that the IRS and state tax authorities actively investigate and prosecute. A preparer who routes a client’s refund through their own account and retains funds without disclosing the fee amount in advance has committed multiple potential violations, including theft, deceptive business practices, and violations of IRS regulations governing tax return preparers.

The Tennessee indictment she mentioned is relevant because it shows this pattern is known and prosecuted at the federal level. The IRS Office of Professional Responsibility and the Department of Justice Tax Division have both pursued cases involving exactly this kind of refund diversion scheme, and her situation fits the pattern they look for.

Filing a complaint with the IRS is the most important immediate step

She should file Form 14157, Complaint Against Tax Return Preparer, with the IRS immediately. This form is specifically designed for complaints about preparer misconduct, and the IRS takes refund diversion cases seriously because they undermine the tax filing system and harm vulnerable taxpayers. She should also file Form 14157-A, Tax Return Preparer Fraud or Misconduct Affidavit, which documents the specific harm she experienced.

These complaints trigger an investigation by the IRS Return Preparer Office and can result in the preparer losing their PTIN, being banned from preparing returns, and being referred for criminal prosecution. While filing a complaint doesn’t guarantee she gets her money back, it puts the case on record with the agency that has the most tools to act on it.

State-level complaints and law enforcement

She should also file a complaint with her state’s attorney general consumer protection division and with any state licensing board that oversees tax preparers in her state. Some states require tax preparers to be licensed or registered, and a complaint to the licensing authority can result in the preparer losing their ability to operate.

Filing a police report for theft is also worth doing. Keeping a client’s refund without disclosing the fee amount is theft by most state definitions, and a police report creates a law enforcement record that supports other actions she takes. It also opens the possibility of criminal prosecution at the state level, which sometimes moves faster than federal tax enforcement.

Small claims court as a direct recovery path

She can sue the preparer in small claims court for the $3,500 without hiring an attorney. Small claims limits vary by state but $3,500 falls within the range in most jurisdictions. She’ll need documentation of the original refund amount, proof that she received only $500, any written or verbal communications about the fee arrangement, and any receipts or agreements she signed. If she has text messages, emails, or other records showing the preparer described the arrangement without disclosing the fee amount, those are her strongest evidence.

A judgment in small claims court doesn’t guarantee collection, but it creates a legal obligation the preparer must satisfy and gives her additional tools to pursue collection if the preparer doesn’t pay voluntarily.

The CFPB and FTC are additional options

If the preparer used any kind of financial product to route the refund, such as a refund transfer product offered through a bank or financial services company, she can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau against that financial product provider. The Federal Trade Commission also accepts complaints about deceptive business practices and uses complaint data to identify patterns that lead to enforcement actions.

None of these paths guarantees immediate recovery, but pursuing multiple avenues simultaneously creates the most pressure on the preparer and gives her the best chance of seeing the money returned.

Featured on Cents + Purpose: