When the mom opened her tax return paperwork, she expected a routine filing. Same kids. Same household. Same single-parent math she had done every year since the divorce. What she did not expect was the notice telling her her return had a problem.
Her ex had already filed. And he had claimed the kids.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
The shock was immediate. He had not paid child support in months. He did not cover school expenses. He did not handle medical appointments or daily care. Yet he had beaten her to the IRS and taken the tax credits tied to the children she supported full time.
At first, she assumed it had to be a mistake. Then came the anger. Then confusion. And finally the realization that the tax rules were not as straightforward as she believed.
The first reaction is usually disbelief
Like many custodial parents, the mom believed that paying support or being involved mattered most. In her mind, the idea that someone who contributed little financially could legally claim the kids felt impossible.
But federal tax law does not work on fairness. It works on definitions.
The IRS does not ask who paid more. It does not ask who tried harder. It looks at residency rules and paperwork. That distinction is where many parents get blindsided.
Why child support does not factor into tax claims
One of the hardest truths the mom had to accept was that child support and taxes operate in separate systems. Support payments are handled through state courts. Dependency claims are handled through federal tax law.
Child support is not deductible by the payer and is not taxable to the recipient. It also does not give a parent the right to claim a child on a tax return, a rule explained in IRS guidance on how child support is treated for tax purposes.
For this mom, that meant her ex’s failure to pay support did not automatically disqualify him from trying to claim the kids.
Residency matters more than almost anything else
The next question became where the kids actually lived. The IRS defines the custodial parent as the parent the child lived with for the greater number of nights during the year. Not who the court order favors. Not who feels more responsible. Nights on paper.
In this case, the mom had the kids nearly every night. School records, medical forms, and calendars backed that up. Under IRS rules, she was clearly the custodial parent.
But that alone did not stop the issue.
How the ex was able to claim the kids anyway
The ex filed early. He listed the children. The IRS system accepted his return because there was no conflicting claim yet. When the mom later tried to file electronically, her return was rejected.
This is how many of these situations unfold. The IRS does not decide who is right at the moment of filing. It flags the issue only after two people claim the same child.
By then, the damage feels done.
What happens after both parents claim the same child
Once duplicate claims occur, the IRS steps in. Both parents receive notices asking them to prove eligibility. Documentation becomes critical. School records. Medical records. Proof of address. Calendars showing where the child slept.
The IRS applies its tie-breaker rules to determine who qualifies, rules based on residency and filing status rather than personal circumstances. Those standards are outlined in the IRS rules on how a qualifying child is determined when more than one person tries to claim the same dependent.
For the mom, this meant months of waiting. Delayed refunds. Stress. And the emotional toll of having to prove something she lived every day.
Why this keeps happening to parents like her
This situation is more common than people realize. Many parents assume divorce decrees automatically control tax claims. They do not. Others assume paying support creates eligibility. It does not.
The system favors whoever files first, then sorts it out later. That reality leaves custodial parents vulnerable when an ex decides to claim children improperly.
What parents should take from her experience
For parents in similar situations, documentation matters. Keep records showing where the child lives. Keep school and medical paperwork. Track nights if custody is shared.
If your return is rejected due to a duplicate claim, filing by mail and responding to IRS notices may be necessary. A tax professional can help guide the process.
Most importantly, parents should know this before it happens. Understanding the rules early can prevent a stressful and expensive fight later.
More From Cents + Purpose: