A man and his fiancée bought a newly built home earlier this year. Just months later, they’re separating, and she’s told him to sell the house and let her know when it’s done so she can move out.
He doesn’t think selling makes sense right now. Between what he still owes, the cost of selling, and the builder down the street offering better deals on brand-new homes, he’s worried he’d go through the whole process and walk away with almost nothing.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
A New Build Bought This Year
The couple moved to a new city and bought a new-construction home for about $275,000. It’s a two-story house with four bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and roughly 2,175 square feet.
It was meant to be the start of their life together. Now the house has become one of the biggest questions in their breakup.
A Corner Lot With Mature Trees
He’s proud of the home and believes it stands out from others nearby. It sits on a corner lot with a large backyard and mature trees, which many new-construction homes in the area don’t have.
The house also already has blinds, landscaping, and other finishing touches. Those extras can cost buyers thousands of dollars and plenty of time to add to a brand-new home.
$228,000 Still Owed
He currently owes about $228,000 on the mortgage. Since they bought only months ago, very little of the loan has been paid down.
In the early years of a mortgage, most of each payment goes toward interest rather than the balance. That means he’s built up only a small amount of equity through payments so far.
Just Sell It
His fiancée has told him to sell the house and let her know when it’s sold, at which point she’ll move out. For her, selling seems like the simplest way to end things.
He sees it differently. He likes the house, can afford it on his own, and doesn’t want to sell if it means taking a major financial loss.
Competing Against the Builder
His biggest concern is that he’d be competing directly with the builder. He estimates his home might sell for $250,000 to $260,000.
Meanwhile, the builder could offer a brand-new, comparable home for around $275,000 with a subsidized interest rate near 4 percent. A buyer with a market rate closer to 6 percent on his house could end up with a higher monthly payment, even though his house costs less.
That makes his home harder to sell. Many buyers focus on monthly payments, and a builder incentive can easily outweigh a lower purchase price.
Selling Costs That Eat Equity
If he sold for $250,000 while owing $228,000, he’d have about $22,000 in equity before any costs. Agent commissions, closing costs, title fees, and possible buyer concessions could easily eat up most or all of that.
Selling costs often run several percent of a home’s price. On a $250,000 sale, that alone could mean $15,000 or more, leaving very little once the mortgage is paid off.
He’d also be giving up a home he’s happy with. If he wanted to buy again, he’d face another round of closing costs and possibly a higher interest rate.
A Mortgage He Can Cover Alone
His monthly payment is about $1,600, and he can afford it on his own. He’s not under pressure to sell to avoid falling behind.
He’s also the only person on the deed and the mortgage. Legally, the house and the loan are in his name alone.
$60,000 From Her Side
There’s one complication. His fiancée gifted $60,000 toward the down payment.
That money could become a sticking point as they separate. Even though she’s not on the deed or the loan, she may feel she’s owed something back, and sorting out how to handle that contribution could weigh heavily on whatever he decides.
He’s getting professional opinions on the home’s value before making a move. For now, he’s leaning toward keeping it, but with a breakup underway and $60,000 of her money tied up in the house, he’s left wondering whether staying put will be as simple as it looks on paper.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: