Three years ago, things fell apart at his fine dining job and he scrambled to piece together enough income to stay afloat. He drove for Uber, worked farmers markets, barbacked at a tourist bar, and eventually delivered pizzas for Domino’s. His girlfriend wanted to move to Austin, so he went, they broke up shortly after, and he ended up transferring into a smaller one-bedroom apartment when the relationship ended.
His car died. A dealership financed him into a used Subaru with 55,000 miles, no money down, over 72 months. Fourteen months later the Subaru blew up at 94,000 miles. Losing the car meant losing his income, so he financed again, this time into a newer Nissan. The Subaru has a warranty he purchased, but the repairs needed to make it drivable are estimated at $13,000, and he still owes $18,800 on the loan for a car that cannot be driven. He is now making payments on two vehicles while only one of them runs.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
On top of that, he owes the IRS a significant amount, owes a mechanic for prior control arm work, and is running monthly bills around $2,900. He is working 65 hours a week and still cannot keep up. He is considering surrendering the Subaru voluntarily, looking into bankruptcy, breaking his lease, and moving in with his grandparents to help care for them while rebuilding financially.
The Subaru Situation and What Voluntary Surrender Actually Does
Voluntarily surrendering the Subaru to Westlake Financial ends his possession of the vehicle but does not end the loan. The lender will sell the car at auction, almost certainly for far less than the $18,800 he owes, and he will be responsible for the deficiency balance, the gap between what the car sells for and what he owes. On a vehicle that needs $13,000 in repairs to be safe to drive, the auction price will be low, potentially leaving him with a deficiency of $15,000 or more that becomes an unsecured debt he still owes.
Calling Westlake to discuss options is worth doing before surrendering, because lenders sometimes have hardship programs, deferral options, or settlement possibilities that are not advertised. He has nothing to lose by calling and explaining the situation plainly.
Whether Bankruptcy Makes Sense
Given the combination of what he is describing, an underwater car loan on an undrivable vehicle, IRS debt, a mechanic debt, and $2,900 in monthly bills he is struggling to cover while working 65 hours a week, bankruptcy deserves serious consideration rather than being treated as a last resort to avoid.
Chapter 7 bankruptcy could discharge the Subaru deficiency balance after surrender, the mechanic debt, and potentially other unsecured obligations. IRS debt is more complicated and generally requires meeting specific age and filing requirements to be dischargeable, but a bankruptcy attorney can evaluate what applies to his situation. Many bankruptcy attorneys offer free initial consultations, and given the complexity of what he is dealing with, getting that evaluation is one of the most useful things he can do right now.
Chapter 13 is another option if he has regular income and wants to keep the Nissan while restructuring debt into a manageable repayment plan. Whether that makes sense depends on the Nissan loan terms and how much he owes on it relative to its value.
The Move to His Grandparents
Moving in with his grandparents while helping care for them is one of the most financially sound options available to him right now, and the fact that it also provides them with support makes it genuinely better than just a cost-cutting measure. Eliminating apartment rent, which is likely a significant portion of his $2,900 in monthly obligations, would free up cash flow immediately and give him room to address the debt pile rather than just servicing it indefinitely.
Breaking a lease has costs, typically a fee equal to one or two months of rent, but those costs may be outweighed by the monthly savings. He should review his lease terms and calculate what early termination would cost versus how many months of savings he would see by moving.
The Restaurant Industry and the Vehicle Problem
His plan to return to fine dining and stop using his personal car for income-generating work is the right instinct. Delivery and rideshare driving in a financed vehicle transfers mechanical wear and depreciation costs to him while the platform takes a significant cut of earnings. Fine dining, particularly in roles like his previous experience, tends to pay better per hour than delivery work and does not destroy his vehicle in the process.
The Nissan needs to stay reliable for commuting and basic transportation. Protecting it means keeping up with maintenance and not using it for commercial purposes, which the plan already accounts for.
The Small Cuts and What They Actually Do
Canceling CarShield, quitting cigarettes, and cutting daily cold brew are the right moves, but they are small levers on a large problem. Those changes might free up $200 to $400 a month depending on his habits. The real financial movement comes from the bigger decisions, what happens with the Subaru, whether bankruptcy makes sense, and whether eliminating rent by moving to his grandparents is viable. The small cuts matter for the discipline they represent and the cash they free up, but they will not solve the structural problem on their own.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: