He has three kids: a 21-year-old daughter, an 18-year-old son, and a 16-year-old still in high school. All three have part-time jobs, they’re respectful, and they generally follow through on what’s asked of them, though usually only after being asked. That last part is what’s driving the conversation.
The older two are adults now, and he’s watching them settle into a comfort that feels less like a soft landing and more like a permanent one. His solution isn’t to push them out. It’s to formalize expectations in a way that mirrors real adult life while still keeping a financial safety net built into the structure.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
The Plan He’s Considering
His proposal for the adult children is $550 a month in rent plus a required $200 a month in personal savings. Of the rent collected, 40 percent would be secretly invested into a Roth IRA in each child’s name, while the remaining 60 percent would go toward household expenses, primarily food. On top of the financial piece, he wants a formal agreement covering basic responsibilities like chores, laundry, keeping their cars clean, and staying on top of general adult tasks.
The 16-year-old isn’t part of this conversation yet, which is the right call. He’s still in high school, still a minor, and the structure isn’t designed for him at this stage. The focus is on the two who have crossed into adulthood and are old enough to start understanding what it actually costs to live somewhere.
Why the Roth IRA Component Changes Everything
The most interesting part of his plan is the 40 percent Roth IRA piece, and it’s the detail that separates this from a standard parent-charges-rent arrangement. If each adult child pays $550 a month, $220 of that is going back to them in the form of retirement contributions they might not make on their own for years. Over time, that quiet investment compounds in ways that a checking account balance never would, and they’d be building a financial foundation without necessarily feeling the full weight of the rent number they’re paying.
That structure also reframes what rent means in this household. It’s not purely a transaction where money leaves their account and funds someone else’s expenses. Part of it is a forced savings mechanism dressed up as a bill, which is honestly how a lot of good financial habits get started.
The Power Struggle Underneath It
He mentions a tension between him and his wife on one side and the adult children on the other, and that dynamic is worth paying attention to because a formal agreement doesn’t automatically resolve it. If the kids experience the new structure as rules being imposed on them rather than expectations being clarified, the same friction that exists now will just attach itself to a new set of line items.
The way the agreement gets introduced matters as much as what’s in it. Framing it as a conversation about what adult life in this household looks like going forward, rather than a policy being handed down, gives the older kids some ownership over the outcome. If the 21-year-old and 18-year-old feel like they had some input into what reasonable expectations look like, they’re more likely to follow through without the same nudging that’s frustrating everyone right now.
What the Agreement Should Actually Cover
The financial piece is the easiest part to put on paper. Rent amount, due date, savings requirement, and the Roth IRA structure are all concrete and measurable. The softer expectations around chores and household responsibilities are where formal agreements tend to get fuzzy, because “helping with small household tasks” means different things to different people and creates room for ongoing negotiation about what counts.
Being specific helps. A list of weekly responsibilities assigned by name, a clear understanding of what clean means for shared spaces, and an agreed-upon process for handling things when expectations aren’t met will reduce the number of conversations that turn into arguments. Vague expectations enforced inconsistently are usually what create power struggles in the first place.
The Balance He’s Actually Looking For
His instinct to prepare his kids for real life without throwing them into it unpaid and underprepared is the right one. Charging rent that partially funds their own retirement, requiring savings, and setting household expectations isn’t a punishment for being comfortable at home. It’s a simulation of the financial and logistical reality they’ll face the moment they leave, delivered in an environment where the stakes are lower and the safety net is still in place.
The goal isn’t to make living at home uncomfortable enough that they leave. It’s to make sure that when they do leave, they’ve already been practicing the habits that make independent life sustainable. That distinction is worth making explicit when he sits down to have the conversation, because it changes the tone from “here are the new rules” to “here’s what we’re building together before you go.”
Featured on Cents + Purpose:
- Man Sold His Car on Facebook Marketplace in April and Got a Letter in May Saying He May Be Liable for a Hit and Run Because the Buyer Never Transferred the Title
- Worried Son Says His 80-Year-Old Mother Stopped Paying Credit Cards and Payday Loans and He’s Afraid Collectors Will Take Whatever She Has Left