She was 13 when the car accident happened in Montana. The case didn’t actually settle until she turned 18, by which point she was living in Idaho. Since she didn’t have a bank account of her own at the time the settlement paid out, her mom signed the check over and deposited the $20,000 into an account under her mother’s control, meant to be held for her.
Four years passed before she learned what actually happened to that money. Her mom had given it to an aunt, who put it into a CD account listed solely in the aunt’s own name. Her name was never added to that account, and while her mom may possibly be listed as a beneficiary, she herself has no access to the money at all.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
Rent Suddenly Tripled, Then Silence
Earlier this year, that same aunt raised the rent on the family from $1,700 to $5,000, a jump severe enough to effectively force them out of the property. Since then, the aunt has cut off all contact, refusing to respond to letters or messages of any kind.
That sequence of events, sudden financial pressure applied by the very person holding onto a settlement that was never legally hers to begin with, followed by complete silence once contact was attempted, raises real concern about whether that money is still intact or accessible at all.
The Money Was Legally Hers From the Start
The settlement itself was awarded directly to her for an injury she personally sustained, and critically, the actual settlement check wasn’t issued and finalized until after she’d already turned 18. That timing matters considerably. Once she reached adulthood, any funds paid out specifically to her stopped being something a parent could manage or redirect on her behalf without her consent, since she was legally capable of handling her own finances by the time the money actually arrived.
She never agreed to have this money placed in her aunt’s name, never had access to the CD account, and by her own account had no knowledge the transfer had even happened until four years after the fact. That combination, a legally awarded settlement, an adult recipient, and money moved into a third party’s exclusive control without consent, points toward a real legal claim worth pursuing.
This Likely Involves More Than One Legal Issue
Depending on exactly how this played out, this situation could touch on several overlapping legal concerns. If her mother deposited and later transferred settlement funds that legally belonged to her as an adult without her authorization, that raises questions of conversion, essentially the civil equivalent of unauthorized use of someone else’s property, or potentially breach of a fiduciary duty if her mother was acting in any custodial capacity over those funds even after she turned 18.
The aunt’s role adds another layer. If she knowingly accepted money that wasn’t legally her mother’s or aunt’s to redirect, particularly once it’s understood the settlement was awarded directly to an adult and never authorized for transfer, that could support a separate claim for the return of those funds, potentially through a demand for return of property or unjust enrichment, depending on how Idaho and Montana law handle the specifics here given the cross-state elements involved.
The Timing Between States Matters for Where This Gets Filed
Since the accident happened in Montana but she was living in Idaho when the settlement finalized, and the funds and the aunt’s CD account may currently be located in either state depending on where everyone actually resides now, an attorney will need to sort out which state’s law and which court actually has jurisdiction over recovering these funds. That’s a detail worth raising directly during an initial consultation, since it affects both where a case would need to be filed and which state’s specific laws around settlement funds, minors, and fiduciary responsibility would apply.
The Kind of Attorney Worth Contacting
Given the mix of issues here, funds tied to a personal injury settlement, questions of parental fiduciary responsibility, and a third party currently holding money that was never legally transferred to her, a good starting point would be an attorney who handles either personal injury settlement disputes specifically, or more broadly, civil litigation involving conversion and recovery of funds.
Some family law attorneys also handle disputes involving money held by relatives on behalf of another family member, so it’s worth asking directly during a consultation whether a given attorney has handled cases involving settlement funds specifically, since that adds a layer of specificity, the money’s original legal designation, that a general civil attorney may not automatically account for.
Many personal injury and civil litigation attorneys offer free initial consultations, making it worth reaching out to two or three specifically to get a sense of how they’d approach recovering the CD funds and whether they see a viable path given the details as she understands them so far.
Documenting Everything Before Moving Forward
Before that first consultation, gathering whatever documentation exists, the original settlement paperwork showing the $20,000 was awarded to her personally and the date it was finalized, any record of the check being signed over to her mother, any communication referencing the CD account or its transfer to her aunt, and records of the recent rent increase and subsequent silence, would give an attorney a much clearer picture to work from immediately, rather than starting entirely from a verbal account of events.
Where This Leaves Her
The money likely isn’t gone for good simply because it currently sits in someone else’s name. A settlement awarded directly to her as a legal adult, moved without her knowledge or consent into an account she has no access to, represents a real, actionable claim rather than a lost cause. Getting documentation together now and consulting with an attorney experienced in either settlement fund disputes or civil recovery claims is the clearest next step toward understanding exactly what legal options exist to get that $20,000 back.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: