He sold his 2008 Cadillac STS three or four years ago after the transfer case failed and the repair estimate came in higher than the car was worth. He gave the buyer the title and keys and moved on. Then he got pulled over recently, and while the officer let him go, he mentioned in passing that two vehicles were still registered in his name, including the Cadillac he had sold years earlier.
The buyer, who he connected with through Facebook Marketplace, is no longer reachable. He cannot find him on Messenger or anywhere else. The Cadillac is out there somewhere, still officially tied to his name, and he has no way to contact the person who is supposed to have taken ownership of it.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
The Risk of Leaving This Unresolved
The scenario he is most right to worry about is liability. If the Cadillac is ever involved in an accident, a traffic violation, or a crime, and his name is still attached to the vehicle registration, he could be contacted by law enforcement, insurers, or attorneys who believe he is the owner. Proving he sold the car years ago is possible if he has documentation, but navigating that process is far more complicated than resolving the title situation now.
Unpaid tolls, parking tickets, or registration fees associated with the vehicle could also appear under his name depending on how the state handles those situations for vehicles with unresolved title transfers. Some states send notices to the registered owner of record, which would be him.
What He Should Have Done and Can Still Do
Most states require sellers to file a notice of sale or release of liability with the DMV within a specific number of days of transferring a vehicle. This filing protects the seller by creating an official record that ownership changed hands on a particular date, regardless of whether the buyer completes the title transfer. If he filed that notice at the time of sale, he already has some protection in place and should locate that documentation.
If he did not file a notice of sale, most states still allow him to do so after the fact. He should go to his state’s DMV website or visit in person and ask about the process for filing a late release of liability or notice of transfer. The specific form and requirements vary by state, but the general process involves providing the vehicle identification number, the date of sale, and whatever information he has about the buyer. Some states accept this filing with minimal documentation. Others may require a bill of sale or other evidence of the transaction.
What to Bring to the DMV
Any documentation from the original sale is worth finding. A bill of sale with the buyer’s name, the sale date, and the purchase price is the most useful item. Text messages, Facebook Marketplace messages if he can locate them, or any other written communication that establishes the sale happened and who the buyer was can support the filing. Even a partial record of the buyer’s name or location could be enough to satisfy the DMV’s requirements for the notice.
If he has nothing at all from the transaction, he should still attempt the filing and explain the situation to the DMV. They can tell him what his options are with the information he has available.
The Title Itself
He gave the buyer the signed title at the time of sale, which means the buyer has what he needs to transfer ownership into his name. The fact that he has not done so after several years suggests either that the car has changed hands again informally, that it is not being driven, or that the buyer has simply never gotten around to completing the process. None of those situations are his responsibility to manage at this point, but all of them are reasons to get his name off the registration as cleanly as possible.
Once he files the release of liability, the DMV will have a record that he relinquished ownership on a specific date. That record protects him going forward even if the buyer never completes the title transfer.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: