Woman looking shocked at her grocery receipt

Grocery stores are packed with sales that look good at first glance. But not every sale saves you money. Some deals lead to wasted food or extra spending down the line. Here are nine grocery deals that seem like bargains but can actually cost you more.

Bulk Items You Don’t Use

People shopping in a warehouse club
Image Credit: A Katz via Shutterstock.

Buying in bulk can seem like a great way to save money, but it only makes sense if you actually use the product. Purchasing massive amounts of items like cereal, flour, or snacks might save you a little upfront, but if you don’t use them before they expire, you’re throwing money away. Stick to buying bulk items that have a long shelf life or that you know you’ll use regularly.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

Pre-Packaged “Convenience” Foods

Image Credit: Aibekovdaniyar via Deposit Photos.

Ready-made meals and snacks are definitely convenient, but they usually come with a higher price tag. A bag of chopped veggies or cooked rice can cost twice as much as prepping it yourself. A little extra effort in the kitchen can lead to big savings over time.

Name-Brand Products

Woman struggling to make a purchase decision in the store
Image Credit: Stokkete via Shutterstock.

Many people assume that name-brand products are always better than generic or store-brand items. But often, there’s very little difference between the two. Whether it’s canned goods, cleaning supplies, or pantry staples, store brands are usually just as good (if not better) and cost a lot less. Don’t fall for the name-brand trap—check the ingredients and compare the prices.

Single-Use Specialty Items

Woman in apron cleaning counter with paper towel rolls
Image Credit: Serezniy via Deposit Photos.

Items that are marketed as “single-use” can quickly pile up in your cart. Think about things like special drink mixes, pre-portioned coffee pods, or individually packaged condiments. While they might seem convenient, these items usually cost more per serving than the larger, bulk alternatives. Try to find multi-use products instead, like a reusable coffee filter or bigger bags of snacks that you can portion yourself.

High-Cost Organic Products

Inside of Trader Joe's store produce section
Image Credit: Mdurson via DepositPhotos.

While organic food is great in many ways, it’s not always worth the extra money—especially when it comes to certain items. For instance, many fruits and vegetables have a minimal difference in nutrient value between organic and non-organic versions. Stick to buying organic for the items that matter most, like produce with thin skins (e.g., apples) and focus on buying conventional for others (e.g., bananas or avocados).

Individually Wrapped Snacks

Rack of Hostess snacks in store
Image Credit: The Image Party via Shutterstock.

Snack-sized portions are a favorite of busy parents and individuals on the go, but they’re usually more expensive than buying in larger quantities. These individually wrapped snacks may seem convenient, but you’re paying for the packaging and the convenience rather than the snack itself. Opt for larger packs and divide the snacks into smaller containers to save money.

Ready-Made Smoothies

Cutting board with berries and smoothie
Image Credit: ComandaX via Deposit Photos.

Pre-made smoothies or smoothie mixes can be tempting, especially if you’re in a rush. However, these often come at a steep price. If you buy frozen fruit and make your own smoothies at home, you can save a significant amount of money. Plus, you get to control the ingredients and make healthier choices without the added sugar and preservatives that can be in store-bought blends.

Pre-Sliced Fruit and Vegetables

Free samples of oranges and grapefruit segments at a grocery store
Image Credit: OlafSpeier via Deposit Photos.

Pre-sliced or pre-cut produce is appealing because it saves you time, but it’s often far more expensive than buying the whole version. Whole fruits and vegetables can be stored for longer and usually come at a fraction of the price. Take a few extra minutes to chop your own produce and enjoy the savings—and often, the better quality.

Multi-Pack Deals That Aren’t Actually a Deal

Man holding two different items comparing prices in a store aisle
Image Credit: Michael Traitov via Shutterstock.

Multi-packs or “value packs” of certain products can trick you into thinking you’re getting more for your money. But, in reality, you’re often paying more per unit. Always check the price per ounce or per item when buying multi-packs. Sometimes buying smaller quantities (or a different brand) can be a better deal in the long run.

Low-Cost “Healthy” Alternatives

Man pushing shopping cart in grocery store
Image Credit: 1000 Words via Shutterstock.

Certain “healthy” products, like protein bars or low-fat versions of snacks, often cost more than their regular counterparts. Many of these items are marketed as being healthier, but they aren’t always the best choice for your budget. Instead, focus on whole foods like fruits, vegetables, and grains that offer more nutritional value at a lower cost.

Avoid the Trap of “Deals”

Sale signs in a store window with a person looking in
Image Credit: Tommy Ngai TAk Yeung via Shutterstock.

Grocery shopping is full of tempting deals, but not all of them are actually saving you money. By being mindful of the products you buy, comparing prices, and focusing on what’s truly necessary, you can avoid wasting money on deals that end up costing you more. Don’t let flashy sales and advertisements fool you—sometimes the best deal is the one that doesn’t sound like a deal at all.

21 Budget Grocery Shopping Tips To Stretch Your Food Budget

Man and woman sitting on the ground in a grocery store eating junk food
Image Credit: Dean Drobot via Shutterstock.

Are you having trouble finding extra money in your budget to save or pay off debt? Did you know that one of the easiest categories to cut is your food budget? Most families drastically overspend on food each month but there are many ways to do budget grocery shopping and stretch your food budget without feeling deprived. 21 Budget Grocery Shopping Tips to Stretch Your Food Budget