Blonde woman leaning over laughing

Frugal living is supposed to simplify your life and save you money, but not every penny-pinching habit is worth your time. Some ideas, while they may seem resourceful, end up costing you more—whether that’s in lost time, extra stress, or even hidden expenses. Here are 13 frugal practices that just don’t justify the effort.

Making Your Own Laundry Detergent

Woman pouring a blue bottle of laundry detergent into a white cap.

Sure, making detergent sounds like a fun DIY project, but it rarely pays off. It’s messy, time-consuming, and often not as effective as store-bought brands. Plus, if your homemade concoction damages your clothes or your washing machine, any savings disappear. High-quality detergent goes on sale often—just stock up then.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

Extreme Couponing

Hand holding a pile of coupons
Image Credit: Payphoto via Deposit Photos.

Those TV shows about extreme couponing make it look thrilling, but the reality isn’t so glamorous. Sorting coupons, chasing deals, and planning grocery trips around sales can take hours. Often, you end up buying things you don’t even need, just because they’re “on sale.” Time spent coupon hunting could be better spent elsewhere.

Driving to Multiple Stores To Save a Few Bucks

Inside of a Trader Joe's store
Image Credit: Mdurson via DepositPhotos.

Hopping between three or four grocery stores to snag the cheapest deal on bananas or toilet paper might seem smart, but factor in gas costs and time lost. Often, what you save on the item gets canceled out by the expense of getting there. Stick to one or two convenient stores with fair prices.

Skimping on Reliable Health Insurance

Medical bills on a table with money
Image Credit: Motortion via Deposit Photos.

Choosing the lowest-cost insurance might save a tiny bit monthly, but when things go wrong, you’ll regret it. Subpar insurance can leave you footing a massive bill after an accident or health emergency. Sometimes, the cheapest coverage ends up being the most expensive mistake.

Handwashing All Your Clothes

Woman hand washing clothing
Image Credit: Mariakray via Shutterstock.

Unless your wardrobe is all silk and cashmere, handwashing your laundry is a dated habit that really doesn’t save much. Modern washing machines are energy-efficient and use very little detergent. Spending hours scrubbing is hardly worth the time, typically uses more water, and may not even prolong the life of your clothes as intended.

Sleeping in Freezing Cold Rooms to Save Heat

Man sleeping on his side in bed
Image Credit: Ground Picture via Shutterstock.

Turning the thermostat down a few degrees is one thing, but shivering under three blankets all winter? Probably not worth it. When the cold creeps into the house, it can increase the risk of pipes freezing and bursting. Plus, it’s just plain uncomfortable. Heat your home to a livable level and cut costs in other, less miserable ways.

Reusing Disposable Items

Person putting an empty plastic waster bottle in a pile of bottles
Image Credit: Bignai via Shutterstock.

Washing and reusing plastic bags, aluminum foil, or paper plates might feel thrifty, but the effort you spend cleaning these items usually outweighs any financial benefit. Many disposable products weren’t designed to last, so this habit can even lead to health or safety issues.

Always Buying the Cheapest Tools or Home Supplies

Table filled with tools
Image Credit: AlexKosev via Deposit Photos.

There’s nothing frugal about buying a cheap hammer or low-quality paint when you’ll need to replace them sooner. Investing in decent tools and materials once can save you money long-term. Sometimes, you truly get what you pay for.

DIY-ing Every Little Thing

Woman painting a small table
Image Credit: Ground Picture via Shutterstock.

DIY projects can save money, but lack of skill can lead to bigger expenses. Attempting plumbing, electrical work, or even sewing without know-how often results in costly mistakes. Sometimes, it’s smarter (and cheaper) to call a professional instead.

Avoiding Regular Car Maintenance

Man sitting in car touching radio
Image Credit: ArturVerkhovetskiy via Deposit Photos.

You might think skipping oil changes or tire rotations saves money, but this habit leads to more significant repair bills. Vehicles need basic upkeep to last. Neglecting maintenance increases the likelihood of breakdowns, and that’ll cost you way more than you saved.

Buying in Bulk When You Don’t Need To

People shopping in a warehouse club
Image Credit: A Katz via Shutterstock.

Stocking up on bulk items feels like you’re getting a great deal…until you realize seventeen jars of pasta sauce are expiring. Bulk deals only work for non-perishables you’ll actually use. Otherwise, you’re just wasting money and pantry space.

Saving on Shoes (at the Expense of Your Feet)

Man's feet showing one looking poor and tattered and one looking to be in business shoes and pants
Image Credit: Enrique Ramos via Shutterstock.

Cheap shoes often lack support, wear out fast, and can leave you with foot pain. Spending a bit more on decent footwear pays off in comfort and longevity. Treating foot issues caused by bad shoes is far more expensive than buying quality upfront.

Skipping Tiny Pleasures That Actually Matter

Young woman sticking her tongue out and drinking coffee
Image Credit: PeopleImages.com via Deposit Photos.

Cutting small joys like your favorite coffee or a music streaming subscription doesn’t really add up in the grand scheme. When those little treats make your day better, the recurring cost is worth it. Over-focusing on minor expenses can drain your happiness without real financial benefit.

Focus on the Goal

Woman putting coin into a piggy bank
Image Credit: Tommaso1979 via Deposit Photos.

Saving money is the goal, but not all habits are worth your time, comfort, or effort. Focus on frugal strategies that offer significant returns and improve your life in the long run. It’s about balance—spending smarter while knowing when it’s okay to say, “Nope, not worth it.”

9 Crazy Simple Hacks Frugal People Swear By

Blonde woman with short hair and sunglasses
Image Credit: Sarymsakov via Deposit Photos.

Frugality doesn’t mean living a life devoid of pleasure; rather, it’s about making smarter choices and being conscious about where your money goes. By adopting a few simple practices, you can significantly improve your financial situation without feeling deprived. Discovering new ways to save just may become your next favorite hobby. Here are nine simple frugal hacks you can start today. 9 Crazy Simple Hacks Frugal People Swear By

15 Weird Things Frugal People Refuse to Spend Money On

Woman popping out of hundred dollar bills
Image Credit: Feverpitch via Deposit Photos.

Frugal living is about stretching every dollar to its limit and prioritizing needs over wants. This lifestyle leads to avoiding unnecessary purchases, even ones others might consider normal. Here are some of the quirkiest things frugal folks refuse to spend money on. 15 Weird Things Frugal People Refuse to Spend Money On