Woman holding her credit card and frowning

Paying off debt is a big goal for a lot of people—but some strategies do more harm than good. What sounds like a smart move at first can end up slowing you down or costing you more in the long run. If you’re trying to make real progress, it helps to know what to avoid. Here are nine debt payoff moves that can backfire fast.

Putting All Extra Cash Into Debt

Woman looking stressed about her debt
Image Credit: Sbartsmediagmail.co via Deposit Photos.

Putting every extra dollar you have into debt might seem like a quick way to become debt-free, but it can leave you with little room for other important expenses. Life happens—unexpected bills or emergencies could leave you scrambling if your emergency fund is empty. Instead, balance paying down debt with building up your savings to ensure you’re covered when life throws a curveball.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

Paying Only the Minimum Payments

Man paying cash for a down payment for a car
Image Credit: MrCat.com.ua via Deposit Photos.

Paying the minimum payment on your debt may seem like a safe, easy option. But if you only make minimum payments, you’re likely paying way more in interest over time. The balance grows slowly, and you end up paying off a lot less of the principal. Try to pay more than the minimum to save money in the long run and clear your debt faster.

Consolidating Debt Without a Plan

Chase Sapphire Reserve credit card
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Debt consolidation can sound like a great idea—it combines multiple payments into one lower payment, right? But without a solid plan, consolidating debt can just be a temporary fix. If you don’t change your spending habits or address the root causes of your debt, you may find yourself back in the same spot, plus paying fees or higher interest rates on the consolidated loan.

Focusing Only on High-Interest Debt

Woman holding credit card and looking very stressed
Image Credit: Photobyphotoboy via Deposit Photos.

While paying off high-interest debt first makes sense, don’t neglect the lower-interest debt in the meantime. Sometimes, juggling only high-interest loans can feel overwhelming, and the low-interest ones can drag on for years. A more balanced approach is often better, where you pay extra on the highest-interest debt but still chip away at others to prevent them from piling up.

Draining Your Retirement Fund to Pay Off Debt

401k paperwork sitting on desk with a pen
Image Credit: Garyphoto via Deposit Photos.

You may think that using your retirement savings to pay off debt is a quick fix, but this can cost you big in the long run. Withdrawing money from your 401(k) or IRA could come with penalties, and you’ll lose out on the long-term growth of that money. It’s better to focus on other debt payoff methods while contributing to your retirement fund whenever possible.

Borrowing More to Pay Off Debt

One man giving another man cash
Image Credit: Andy Dean Photography via Shutterstock.

It may seem logical to borrow more money to pay off your debt, but this strategy can lead to even more debt. Taking out a new loan to pay off credit cards or other debts may provide temporary relief, but you could end up in a cycle of borrowing and paying with no real progress. Instead, focus on cutting back on spending and using the snowball or avalanche method to pay off debt.

Ignoring Your Credit Score While Paying Off Debt

Cell phone laying on table with credit score showing on the screen
Image Credit: Mgequivalents via Deposit Photos.

A great credit score can save you money in the long run, especially when it comes to loans or mortgages. While paying off debt is important, ignoring your credit score along the way could leave you with a lower score, even if you’re making progress with your debt. Try to keep track of your credit score and address any discrepancies while you pay down your debt to avoid long-term damage.

Using Debt as a Buffer for Emergencies

Man holding a jar filled with money and labeled "emergency"
Image Credit: Yanishevska.photo via Deposit Photos.

Relying on debt as a safety net during emergencies can be a slippery slope. When you’re in the habit of putting emergencies on credit cards or taking out loans to cover expenses, it can keep you in a cycle of debt. Build up your emergency fund before relying on credit so that you have a cushion to fall back on when unexpected costs arise.

Only Paying Off Debt and Forgetting About Saving

Woman saving cash in glass jars
Image Credit: PeandBen via Deposit Photos.

Paying off debt is a great goal, but don’t forget to save for the future, too. While it might feel like you’re making progress by focusing solely on your debt, neglecting your savings can leave you in a bind when unexpected expenses come up. Balance paying down debt with building an emergency fund and contributing to savings so that you’re not caught off guard when something happens.

Ignoring Small Debts to Focus on the Big Ones

Outside of house with a car in driveway and a pretty sky
Image Credit: Patryk_Kosmider via Deposit Photos.

It’s tempting to focus on the larger debts first, but ignoring small debts can create problems in the long run. Those smaller balances can add up and start to feel overwhelming if you don’t address them. Start with a balanced approach, paying extra toward high-interest debts while still making headway on smaller ones to avoid letting them pile up.

Moving Too Quickly Without a Clear Strategy

Young woman covering her face with her hands while she's trying to pay bills and manage her money
Image Credit: Pormezz via Shutterstock.

Debt payoff requires a strategy, and moving too quickly without one can lead to mistakes. Jumping into debt payments without a plan can cause you to miss opportunities to save on interest or make the best use of your money. Instead, take the time to create a realistic plan that includes a budget, tracking your progress, and adjusting as needed.

Don’t Let Debt Payoff Plans Backfire

Man sitting on the couch smiling at a pink piggy bank with money
Image Credit: Belchonock via Deposit Photos.

The road to debt freedom isn’t always straightforward, and some methods that seem like good ideas may end up making things harder. It’s crucial to find a strategy that works for your unique situation and to be mindful of the potential pitfalls. By being aware of the common debt payoff mistakes, you can avoid unnecessary setbacks and work toward becoming debt-free in a sustainable way.

Want simple tips to save more, stress less, and take control of your money delivered straight to your inbox? Subscribe to our free newsletter and check out these popular posts: How to Save Thousands on Your Grocery Budget and 5 Reasons Index Funds Are the Best Investment for New Investors. Follow Cents + Purpose on MSN for more helpful money tips!