Couple talking on couch

A woman is set to marry her fiancé on New Year’s Eve. From the start, they agreed on a prenuptial agreement, separate personal accounts, and a joint account for shared bills.

As the wedding gets closer, he’s stopped talking about the prenup and wants her to put $200,000 toward a down payment on a future home, while keeping his current house entirely in his name. When she wrote protections into the prenup to get her share back in a divorce, he refused, and now she’s prepared to call off the wedding.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

New Year’s Eve Wedding Plans

The couple is planning to marry on New Year’s Eve. Between them, they’ll be raising four children.

Blending families can bring financial complications. Housing, childcare, and long-term planning all become bigger questions when kids are involved.

From the beginning, she wanted those details clear. She hoped a prenup would protect both of them and their children.

Similar Incomes, Different Situations

She earns about $163,000 a year, plus some inconsistent child support. He makes about $133,000, plus about $30,000 in veterans benefits, though he also pays child support.

After those adjustments, their incomes are fairly close. Both are financially stable.

He’s also going back to school and expects to graduate in 2028. He’ll likely take a pay cut and work less in the summers to finish his program.

Selling Her House to Move Into His

She owns a home with a mortgage of about $1,824 a month. Because she bought it about three years ago, selling would only net her around $30,000.

He owns a home with a mortgage of about $823 a month. He’s lived there longer and could make roughly $100,000 if he sold it.

Because of his circumstances, she’s the one moving into his house. That means selling her home and giving up her own property.

Prenup Talk That Faded

At first, they both wanted a prenup to protect retirement accounts and other assets. They also agreed to keep separate personal accounts and a joint account for shared bills.

Lately, he’s stopped bringing up the prenup. He’s even suggested combining their finances.

She’s stayed committed to the original plan. She’s spent time researching prenups, including how to protect her children if she dies or the couple divorces.

$200,000 Down Payment Request

Her fiancé wants to keep paying all the bills for his current home after she moves in. He doesn’t want to add her name to the house.

Instead, he wants her to pay her own bills and put $200,000 toward a down payment on a larger home for their family. That would also include buying land.

She’d still be covering her own expenses, including childcare, a car payment, and student loans. Those costs total more than $2,000 a month.

His House Stays His Alone

In the prenup, she included a clause stating that if they divorce, she’d get back the percentage she contributed to the down payment and the home. She also proposed splitting future housing costs based on income.

Since he’ll likely earn less while in school, she would probably pay a larger share. On top of the $200,000 down payment, her total contribution would be at least $230,000.

He refused. He argued that letting her live in his house for about two years should be enough to balance out her contribution.

Contributions That Don’t Add Up

She estimates that over two years, his share of housing costs, including the mortgage and utilities, would be about $26,400. That’s far less than the $230,000 she’d be putting in.

Based on the down payment alone, she figures she’d be entitled to about 89 percent and he’d get 11 percent if they split it by contribution. She’s not asking for every dollar back, only her fair share.

She suggested other options, like adding her to his house and splitting proceeds 50/50, or using the profit from his house toward the new down payment while they both pay off debt and save. He rejected every idea.

Mediation or a Canceled Wedding

She reminded him that both of their lawyers could meet to help create a fair agreement. He said it wouldn’t matter because he wouldn’t agree no matter what.

She told him that without protections, there won’t be a wedding. She isn’t willing to risk leaving herself and her children without a home while he keeps his property and benefits from her money, and she’s left wondering whether this disagreement reveals a deeper problem she can’t ignore before New Year’s Eve.

Featured on Cents + Purpose: