This article may contain affiliate links. See our disclosure policy for more info.

Professional woman looking angry while using her laptop

An hourly employee was told her company’s Saturday food bank volunteer day was totally voluntary. Then her manager pointed out that community involvement is on the review form and later emailed the team that she’d be noting attendance in reviews.

So she logged the four hours she spent there on her timesheet. Now her manager wants them removed, and the employee is trying to decide whether leaving them on is fair or whether it makes her look like she only went for the paycheck.

💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET

Hourly Worker and the Handbook Rule

She’s paid by the hour, and her company handbook says hourly employees must record all time worked. That rule shaped how she approached the event.

For hourly workers, every hour matters. Four hours of pay can make a real difference in a weekly paycheck, especially with rising living costs.

She wanted to follow company policy. She didn’t want to leave work time off her records.

Saturday Volunteer Day at a Food Bank

Every November, her company organizes a volunteer day at a local food bank. This year, it was scheduled on a Saturday.

Volunteer events can be a great way for employees to give back. They can also build teamwork outside the office.

Still, Saturday events can be harder for some employees to attend. Family obligations, second jobs, or personal plans can make weekends less flexible.

Totally Voluntary, With a Catch

Her manager’s invitation called the event totally voluntary. But it also said this was the kind of thing leadership notices.

During a one-on-one meeting, the employee asked if attending was required. Her manager said no.

Then her manager added that community involvement is part of the review form. She said that if she were the employee, she would go.

Community Involvement on the Review Form

The employee checked the review form. It does include a section on community involvement.

Performance reviews can affect raises, bonuses, and promotions. Even small differences in a review can affect future pay.

Knowing that, she decided to attend. It no longer felt completely optional.

Four Hours Sorting Canned Food

She spent four hours at the food bank sorting canned goods. Her manager checked everyone in with a clipboard at the door.

The event itself was meaningful. Helping a food bank can support families who are struggling to afford groceries.

Still, she viewed the time as work-related. The company organized it, and her manager tracked attendance.

Noted in Reviews

After the event, her manager emailed the team to thank everyone who came. She said she’d be noting it in reviews.

That message made the employee even more confident the event affected her job. If attendance counted toward reviews, it seemed like more than a purely voluntary activity.

She had already researched the issue. She found that volunteer time generally doesn’t need to be paid when it’s truly voluntary and there’s no pressure or penalty tied to attending.

Logging the Time

She added the four hours to her timesheet under “Other.” Her note simply said it was the company food bank day.

The next day, her manager asked her to remove the hours. She said it was a volunteer event and nobody else had logged it.

The employee explained what she’d found about voluntary events. She pointed out that the email said attendance would be noted in reviews.

Asked to Remove the Hours

Her manager said that wasn’t what she meant and that everyone else went because they wanted to. When the employee asked what would happen to the reviews of people who didn’t attend, her manager said she’d have to think about it.

Now the employee is torn. She could remove the hours to avoid looking like she only cared about being paid, or keep them on because the event appeared tied to her performance review, and she’s left wondering which choice is fair to both her paycheck and her place on the team.

Featured on Cents + Purpose: