She just finished her junior year of high school, has a 4.2 GPA and a 1440 SAT score, and has been planning for college with a $60,000 fund her grandmother left her. Then her parents told her something they’d apparently been avoiding for a while, which is that her father hasn’t filed or paid his taxes in roughly 20 years. He owns a small business and according to her parents the reason it went on this long is that dealing with business taxes felt too stressful to address. She remembers him telling her he had an accountant handling things. She’s now fairly certain that wasn’t true.
Her mother files her taxes consistently and earns less income than her father. Their combined household income is somewhere around $75,000 per year based on what little her parents have shared. Her mother and grandmother co-own the house they live in, and her father owns the building where his business operates. The IRS, as far as she knows, has never contacted the family about the missing returns, which she finds confusing but is also grateful for in the most immediate sense.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
What she’s worried about now is FAFSA. She understands enough about financial aid to know that the application depends heavily on tax return information, and she doesn’t know whether her father’s 20-year gap in filings makes that process impossible, complicated, or something that can be worked around. Her parents say they’re going to try to deal with the missing filings, but she’s not confident they’ll follow through and has no sense of how long it would take even if they did.
What FAFSA actually requires and where the problem sits
FAFSA uses tax information to calculate a family’s Expected Family Contribution, which determines what aid a student qualifies for. For dependent students, that calculation pulls from both parents’ financial information, which means her father’s unfiled returns create a direct obstacle. The IRS Data Retrieval Tool that FAFSA uses to pull tax information automatically won’t have anything to retrieve for years her father didn’t file, and fabricating or omitting information on a federal financial aid application creates legal exposure that would be far worse than the tax situation itself.
The realistic path through this involves her father actually filing the missing returns, or at least the most recent ones, before her FAFSA applications go in. Financial aid offices deal with complicated tax situations more often than most people realize, and many have processes for handling cases where returns are in progress, recently filed after a delay, or otherwise outside the standard timeline. What they don’t have a process for is working with no information at all.
What her options look like right now
Her $60,000 college fund covers community college or her local university without financial aid, which means she has a real fallback that many students in complicated situations don’t have access to. That’s worth acknowledging because it changes the stakes of the FAFSA situation from catastrophic to limiting. She’s not choosing between college and no college. She’s potentially choosing between her local options and a broader range of schools that become accessible with aid.
Scholarships that don’t require FAFSA are worth pursuing aggressively in parallel. Merit-based scholarships from private organizations, local foundations, and some colleges themselves don’t always tie eligibility to federal financial aid applications, and with a 4.2 GPA and a 1440 SAT she’s competitive for a meaningful range of them. Colleges with strong merit aid programs sometimes offer substantial awards to academically strong applicants regardless of FAFSA status, and identifying those schools early gives her more options to work with.
Whether she can file based only on her mother’s information
The dependency rules on FAFSA are strict and don’t allow a student to choose which parent’s information to include simply because one parent’s situation is cleaner than the other’s. As a dependent student she’s required to report both parents’ financial information if they live together, and since her parents are still together and living in the same household, her father’s information has to be included.
Becoming an independent student for FAFSA purposes has a narrow set of qualifying circumstances, being 24 or older, married, a veteran, an emancipated minor, or meeting a few other specific criteria. At 17 and living with both parents, she doesn’t currently meet any of those thresholds. That said, some financial aid offices have professional judgment processes that allow them to make exceptions in unusual family circumstances, and her situation is unusual enough that it’s worth having a direct conversation with financial aid offices at schools she’s interested in attending.
What she should do before senior year starts
The most useful thing she can do right now is push her parents to get a tax professional involved immediately, not eventually. A tax attorney or CPA with experience in delinquent filings can assess what the last 20 years of unfiled returns actually means in terms of liability, work out a filing and payment plan with the IRS, and give her family a realistic timeline for getting compliant. The IRS has programs specifically designed for people with unfiled returns who come forward voluntarily, and the consequences of addressing it proactively are generally significantly better than waiting for enforcement to begin.
She should also start talking directly to college financial aid offices at schools she’s considering. Explaining the situation honestly, her father’s filing status, the steps her family is taking to address it, and asking what options exist for students in this circumstance is a conversation financial aid counselors are equipped to have. Getting that information directly from the schools she’s applying to gives her a much clearer picture of what her actual options are than trying to navigate it from the outside.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: