It started as one year. Then two. Then somewhere in the middle of the avoidance, the problem became too large to look at directly and so he kept not looking at it. He knew it was serious. He didn’t fully understand how serious until an IRS notice arrived a couple of weeks ago and he finally opened it.
The notice contained the IRS’s own calculation of what he owes, built on estimated income figures that don’t account for deductions, credits, or the actual details of his financial situation across those years. The number on the page doesn’t reflect what he’d actually owe if he filed properly, and that gap is the first piece of useful information he has. The IRS’s substitute returns are almost always less favorable to the taxpayer than returns filed with complete information.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
What He’s Actually Dealing With
Unfiled returns from 2018 through the present means potentially seven years of missing filings depending on the current tax year. The IRS generally requires taxpayers to file the last six years of returns to be considered in good standing, which is the practical starting point for most people in this situation. Returns older than six years are sometimes required as well depending on the circumstances, but six years is the baseline the IRS typically focuses on for compliance purposes.
The substitute return the IRS filed on his behalf using estimated income is a real liability, but it’s not a fixed one. Filing his actual returns replaces the IRS’s estimates with accurate figures, and if deductions and credits weren’t accounted for, the real number is almost certainly lower than what the notice shows. In some cases it’s significantly lower.
Whether He Can Handle This Alone
The honest answer depends on how complicated his financial situation has been across those years. If his income came from a single W-2 employer each year, he had no major life changes like a business, rental property, or significant investments, and his tax situation was relatively straightforward, filing the missing returns himself using tax software is possible. The IRS also has a Volunteer Income Tax Assistance program that provides free help for people with relatively simple situations.
If any of those years involved self-employment income, freelance work, business ownership, or complicated deductions, working with a CPA or enrolled agent is worth the cost. An enrolled agent is a federally licensed tax professional who specializes in IRS matters and can both prepare the returns and communicate with the IRS on his behalf. For a multi-year nonfiling situation, having a professional handle the back returns and the IRS correspondence simultaneously reduces the risk of errors that extend the problem.
Whether the Advertised Resolution Services Are Worth It
Services like Optima Tax Relief and similar companies market heavily to people in exactly this situation, and the marketing is designed to make the problem feel more catastrophic than it needs to be. For straightforward nonfiling situations where the taxpayer is ready to comply and the amounts involved are manageable, a CPA or enrolled agent typically handles everything these services offer at a fraction of the cost.
Tax resolution firms are more appropriate when the situation involves significant assessed penalties, liens, levies, or a need to negotiate a formal installment agreement or offer in compromise with the IRS. If the final amount he actually owes after filing accurate returns is something he can pay or set up a payment plan to address, the resolution services are likely overkill and expensive overkill at that.
What the First Steps Actually Look Like
The starting point is gathering income records for the missing years. W-2s, 1099s, and any other income documentation can be requested directly from the IRS through an account transcript, which is available through the IRS online account portal or by calling the IRS and requesting wage and income transcripts for each year. Those transcripts show what was reported to the IRS under his Social Security number and give him the income figures he needs to prepare accurate returns.
From there, filing the missing returns in order from oldest to most recent with accurate deductions applied gives him an actual liability number to work with rather than the IRS’s estimated one. Once the real returns are filed, if he owes a balance, the IRS offers installment agreements that can spread payments over time, and penalties can sometimes be reduced through a first-time penalty abatement request if his compliance history before 2018 was clean.
What Not Doing Anything Costs
The IRS notice means the agency has already identified him as a nonfiler and taken action. Ignoring it from this point forward escalates the situation in ways that get progressively harder to manage. The IRS has tools available including wage garnishment, bank levies, and tax liens on property that are triggered by continued noncompliance rather than by the original failure to file.
He’s already in a better position than he was two weeks ago simply by having opened the notice and decided to deal with it. The problem is fixable. It’s been seven years in the making and it won’t resolve in a day, but the path from here to compliance is straightforward compared to what continuing to avoid it would eventually cost him.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: