He wasn’t expecting any of it. He sold his 2018 Civic on Facebook Marketplace back in April, took $7,200 in cash, signed the title over, and completed a handwritten bill of sale with the buyer’s name, license number, and all the relevant details. The transaction felt normal. The buyer was friendly, nothing raised any flags, and he walked away thinking it was done.
Then a letter arrived from a Progressive claims adjuster. The car had been involved in a hit and run on May 3rd in Columbus, and because the title was never transferred into the buyer’s name, the state of Ohio still had him listed as the registered owner. The adjuster’s message was blunt. As the registered owner on file, he might be held liable for damages to the other party.
💸 Take Back Control of Your Finances in 2025 💸
Get Instant Access to our free mini course
5 DAYS TO A BETTER BUDGET
What He Has and What He Missed
He called the number on the letter and didn’t get much warmth from the adjuster, who pointed to the registration record and left it there. What he does have is real documentation. A signed title, a handwritten bill of sale with identifying information, and text messages from when the sale was arranged. That paper trail matters, and it tells a clear story about when ownership changed hands and to whom.
What he didn’t do was file a Notice of Transfer with the Ohio BMV within 30 days of the sale, which is what Ohio requires sellers to submit to formally notify the state that a vehicle has changed hands. That step exists specifically to protect sellers from situations like this one. He didn’t know about it at the time, and now he’s sitting with the consequences of that gap.
How Much Trouble He’s Actually In
The signed title and bill of sale are meaningful. They establish that a legitimate sale took place, that he received payment, and that the buyer took possession of the vehicle with documentation in place. In Ohio, a properly signed title is the legal instrument that transfers ownership, and his signature on it is evidence that he completed his side of the transaction correctly.
The Notice of Transfer filing doesn’t change who legally owns the car. What it does is create a timestamp in the state’s records that separates his liability from the buyer’s. Without it, the gap between the April sale and whatever the BMV eventually updates creates room for complications, especially when an insurance company is looking for a registered owner to hold responsible for a May accident.
The buyer is the bigger problem right now. The phone number is disconnected and the Facebook messages are going unanswered, which means the person who actually drove the car on May 3rd is not cooperating and may not be reachable through informal channels.
What He Should Do Right Now
The first move is to file the Notice of Transfer with the Ohio BMV immediately, even though the 30-day window has passed. Filing late is better than not filing at all, and it creates an official record that he reported the transfer. Ohio’s BMV allows this to be done online and it documents his position going forward.
He should also send a formal written response to the Progressive adjuster, not just a phone call. That response should include copies of the signed title, the bill of sale, and the text messages showing the sale arrangement and date. Getting everything in writing creates a paper record of his position and prevents the conversation from living only in phone calls where nothing is documented.
If the adjuster continues to push liability toward him despite the documentation, consulting with an attorney who handles vehicle liability or consumer protection matters in Ohio would be a reasonable next step before anything escalates further. Most offer free initial consultations, and the documentation he has gives an attorney something real to work with.
The Buyer’s Role in This
The person who drove that car on May 3rd made a choice not to transfer the title, which kept the original owner exposed. Whether that was carelessness or something more deliberate is hard to know, but the disconnected phone number and the silence on Facebook don’t suggest someone who’s eager to resolve the situation.
If the buyer can be identified and located through the bill of sale information, Ohio law does allow the seller to pursue the buyer for costs or damages that result from the buyer’s failure to transfer the title. That’s a longer path, but the license number on the bill of sale is a starting point if law enforcement or an attorney needs to trace it.
Where the Documentation Gets Him
He’s not without protection here. The paper trail he has is exactly what exists to handle this kind of dispute, and Ohio courts have consistently recognized that a signed title transfer shifts legal ownership even when the BMV record hasn’t caught up. The Notice of Transfer gap is a real problem, but it’s a procedural one, not a fundamental one. His documentation shows he acted in good faith and completed a legitimate sale.
The worst outcome, being held personally liable for a hit and run he had nothing to do with, is unlikely given what he has on paper. Getting that documentation in front of the right people quickly is what turns unlikely into resolved.
Featured on Cents + Purpose: