Outside view of Costco warehouse store

It seems like now every store has its own generic brand item competing with the name brands they sell. For a long time, those generic brands have gotten a bad rep of not tasting as good or the same. We found a list of items in a forum people said are the same or even better in some cases than their name-brand counterparts.

1. Girl Scout Cookies

Stacks of Girl Scout cookies on the counter
Image Credit: Sheila Fitzgerald via Shutterstock.

A user said, “Aldi makes great Girl Scout cookie ripoffs. Samoas and Thin Mints. Both delicious.”

Someone else added to their comment with, “If you don’t have an Aldi, you can just buy the Keebler version of those at stores year round anyways. Coconut Dreams and Grasshoppers. Keebler is one of the companies that bakes the “real” girl scout cookies.”

2. Over-the-Counter Medicine

Over the counter medication sitting on a pharmacy counter
Image Credit: Kwangmoozaa via Shutterstock.

“I’ve never found any difference in most generic medicine except maybe the pill shape or some special coating. I think the ingredients in medicine are pretty regulated, so it makes sense,” someone said.

3. Nuts

Bowls of mixed nuts
Image Credit: P-fotography via Shutterstock.

Someone shared, “Yeah, I worked for a major packaging company, and I saw a bid where a very large nut company you’ve heard of was bidding on Great Value business and said they were the same nuts as their branded mix.”

4. Cheerios

Bowl of Cheerios and fruit
Image Credit: Elena Veselova via Shutterstock.

“Cheerios at Trader Joe’s. It’s like $3 cheaper than the Cheerios brand name, and it is the same item. They are made in the same factory and just put into different boxes (Cheerios brand on one side and Trader Joe’s brand on the other),” a user shared.

5. Yogurt

Containers of yogurt sitting on a marble slab
Image Credit: New Africa via Shutterstock.

Someone shared, “Great Value yogurt is made by Dannon. It’s Dannons original recipe and has more fruit per ounce than the Dannon brand.”

6. Milk

Person filling glasses with milk
Image Credit: NataliaPopova via Shutterstock.

“Milk. Dairy farmers sell their milk in giant vats. Is generic milk coming from generic cows? Unless it’s organic grass-fed, I don’t believe there is any difference,” a user shared.

7. Coffee

Barista putting a lid on a cup of coffee
Image Credit: Ivan Kurmyshov via Shutterstock.

“Kirkland coffee is Starbucks in a different package. I worked at the factory, and they just change the bag on the machine for a few hours to run some Kirkland,” someone said.

8. Lotion

Someone putting lotion on their hand
Image Credit: Vladimir Gjorgiev via Shutterstock.

A user shared, “Equate has a good lotion equivalent for Vaseline Intensive Care cocoa butter (dark brown bottle). Soft skin smells nice and not too thick.”

9. Chips

Bowl of chips on counter
Image Credit: Jiri Hera via Shutterstock.

Someone said, “I think Lays are not the best regular potato chip. I prefer less salt and less grease. Which is what the Kroger brand is.”

10. Vodka

Filling shot glasses with a bottle of vodka
Image Credit: 5PH via Shutterstock.

“Rumor has it that Kirkland vodka is just Grey Goose in a different bottle, Grey Goose denies it, but honestly, I don’t know enough about vodka, to tell the truth,” someone shared.

11. Batteries

Double AA batteries
Image Credit: mariva2017 via Shutterstock.

A user said, “Generic alkaline batteries from Walgreens. There was a leak from a worker from Duracell that said the batteries were pretty much the same thing, just different packaging.”

12. Garlic Bread

Garlic bread on a cutting board
Image Credit: RomanaMart via Shutterstock.

A user said, “Most store brand garlic bread is the same as the “name brands.” Only change is the wrapper. So Krogers, GFS, Meijer, Great Value, etc. All the same”

13. Spaghetti-Os

Bowl of spaghetti o's noodles
Image Credit: BryanLyon via Shutterstock.

“Aldi Spaghetti-Os are better to the point that I tried name brand Spaghetti-Os once and couldn’t even finish my serving,” someone shared.

14. Canned Goods

Multiple cans of food sitting on a counter
Image Credit: Antonina Vlasova via Shutterstock.

A user shared, “My brother’s line of work has him visit a lot of canning plants. He told me that the same product (corn, peas, etc) will go down the assembly line and be packaged into multiple different branded cans. They just slap a different label on the cans. Same product.”

15. Italian Dressing

Colander filled with salad greens and a mason jar of dressing
Image Credit: Elena Veselova via Shutterstock.

“Great value brand ‘restaurant style’ Italian dressing, it is just as good as the delicious Olive Garden brand Italian dressing and 50% less cost,” one user mentioned.

16. Ice Cream Sandwiches

Stack of ice cream sandwiches
Image Credit: AnjelikaGr via Shutterstock.

Another user replied,” Generic ice cream sandwiches are better than the name brands. The name brands put too much chocolate and are not very good.”

17. Toothpaste

Toothbrush and toothpaste on counter
Image Credit: DUSAN ZIDAR via Shutterstock.

“Toothpaste. Pretty much 99% of toothpaste in the market has the same basic and active ingredients. They mostly differ in flavor, texture, and some active material (whitening agent, charcoal, etc.). Of course, this doesn’t include specialized toothpaste (like some for smokers).”

8 Failproof Ways to Help You Improve Your Finances

Woman in hat working on laptop
Image Credit: GaudiLab via Shutterstock.

Are you sick and tired of being sick and tired? Your finances are out of control, you live paycheck to paycheck, and you are perpetually stressed about money. These eight tips will help you improve your finances…and your life.

8 Failproof Ways to Help You Improve Your Finances

How to Take Your Financial Inventory (and why you should)

Young woman sitting at a table with papers and a laptop looking stressed
Image Credit: Wavebreakmedia via Deposit Photos.

Are you ready to take the proverbial bull by the horns and start cleaning up this financial mess in which you’ve found yourself? The best place to begin is by taking your financial inventory. Here’s how to do it.

How to Take Your Financial Inventory (and why you should)

What Are Sinking Funds? Everything You Need to Know

Woman saving money fast
Image Credit: Ridofranz via Deposit Photos.

If you’re new-ish to the world of budgeting, you might have heard this strange term sinking fund before and wondered what it means. Nope, it’s not a new type of investment; instead, it’s an incredibly helpful budgeting tool you should definitely be using; here’s everything you need to know about sinking funds…

What Are Sinking Funds? Everything You Need to Know

How to Save More Money This Year

Woman standing on sidewalk putting money in her wallet
Image Credit: Boryana Manzurova via Shutterstock.

How would your life change if you saved more money this year than ever before? How would it feel if you could finally save money without struggling? If you’re not currently able to save any money, these eight tips will help you make some major changes and save more money this year.

How to Save More Money This Year

5 Best Financial Tools to Manage Your Money Better

Hands holding money and laptop
Image Credit: Mrz producer via Shutterstock.

Maintaining a budget and staying organized with your finances is crucial. And whether you’re working to get out of debt or struggling to maintain a budget, there are always ways to improve. These financial tools will help you better manage your money.

5 Best Financial Tools to Manage Your Money Better

Inspired by this thread – photos for illustrative purposes only.

Similar Posts